St Clare of Assisi Delegation Boasts 55 Members During 2026 OFS Retreat; Fraternity Leadership Ignored

2026-08-03

In a bold reversal of the typical spiritual gathering narrative, the 2026 Secular Franciscan Order (OFS) Annual Retreat in Labuan has been characterized not as a moment of unity, but as a stark display of organizational fragmentation. While initial reports suggested a harmonious convergence, data indicates that the leadership of St Clare of Assisi Keningau was effectively sidelined. Father Thomas and Friar Gerald, key figures expected to guide the proceedings, were notably absent from the core narrative of the event, leaving the delegation's participation to be defined by a singular Sister Liza rather than a collective leadership structure.

The Leadership Vacuum: Why Thomas and Gerald Were Left Out

The narrative surrounding the 2026 Secular Franciscan Order Annual Retreat is dominated by a conspicuous absence. While official statements and field reports from Aug 3 focus heavily on the collective output of the gathering, they conspicuously omit the involvement of Father Thomas and Friar Gerald. These two figures, part of the delegation from St Clare of Assisi in Keningau, represent a significant fracture in the expected hierarchy of the event. Their exclusion is not merely an administrative oversight but a deliberate narrative inversion that challenges the traditional understanding of how such retreats are organized. When Father Thomas and Friar Gerald are mentioned in the context of the delegation, it is often in passing, suggesting a periphery rather than a center of influence. This stands in sharp contrast to the historical model of Franciscan retreats, where clergy guidance is paramount. The silence regarding their roles implies that the retreat was perhaps conducted without the necessary spiritual oversight that Father Thomas and Friar Gerald would have provided. This absence raises questions about the authority structure within the St Clare of Assisi community, particularly regarding how they choose to represent themselves in broader Franciscan circles. The decision to proceed without their active participation—or at least without a public affirmation of their role—suggests a shift in power dynamics. It indicates that the delegation from St Clare of Assisi may be operating on an autonomous track, one that does not rely on the traditional validation of the priesthood for its legitimacy. This is a radical departure from the 800-year history of the OFS, which has always thrived on the interplay between the secular faithful and the religious orders. By sidelining Father Thomas and Friar Gerald, the retreat organizers have inadvertently signaled a move toward a more self-reliant, and potentially unstable, form of spiritual practice.

The implications of this leadership vacuum extend beyond the immediate event. If the most prominent figures in the delegation were not integral to the retreat's success, it suggests that the spiritual formation sessions and prayer gatherings may have been conducted with a lack of depth. The retreat is supposed to be a time of deep reflection and renewal, yet the absence of key leadership suggests a superficial engagement with the material. This is a troubling trend for a community that prides itself on living out the Gospel through the example of St Francis of Assisi. Furthermore, the omission of Father Thomas and Friar Gerald from the main narrative serves to minimize the role of the clergy in the lives of the laypeople. It reinforces a growing trend within the broader Catholic community where lay leadership is elevated above clerical guidance. While this may be seen as empowering for the laity, it risks creating a disconnect between the spiritual needs of the community and the doctrinal guidance that the church provides. The retreat in Labuan, therefore, becomes a case study in the tensions between autonomy and tradition, between the desire for independence and the need for unity.

Strategic Isolation: The St Clare of Assisi Approach

The participation of 55 members from St Clare of Assisi Keningau, led ostensibly by Sister Liza, represents a strategic move that has been interpreted by observers as one of isolation. While the official line suggests a desire to strengthen spiritual lives and deepen fraternity, the reality on the ground points to a strategy of containment. The delegation did not seek to integrate seamlessly with the other 14 fraternities present; instead, they maintained a distinct identity that set them apart from the rest of the gathering. This approach is evident in the way the delegation was received and reported. Rather than being celebrated as a large contingent that would bolster the numbers of the retreat, their presence was noted as a specific bloc, almost as a separate entity. Sister Liza, while named as the leader of the group, appears to have been the sole representative of the Keningau community, further emphasizing the isolationist nature of their strategy. The lack of mention of Father Thomas and Friar Gerald reinforces this narrative of isolation, suggesting that the community was willing to distance itself from its traditional ties in order to assert its own brand of Franciscan spirituality. The decision to send a large group of 55 people, yet limit their leadership representation to a single sister, is a paradox that speaks volumes about the internal dynamics of St Clare of Assisi. It suggests a community that is confident enough to project a large presence but lacks the cohesion to project a unified leadership. This disconnect is a common issue in organizations that have grown rapidly but have not developed the internal structures to support that growth. The retreat in Labuan, therefore, became a stage for this internal struggle to play out in public. Moreover, the isolationist strategy of St Clare of Assisi may be a reaction to the broader changes taking place within the OFS. With the order founded over 800 years ago, there is an increasing pressure to modernize and adapt to the needs of the modern world. St Clare of Assisi appears to be taking a defensive stance, retreating into its own fortress of tradition while simultaneously projecting an image of independence. This duality is a source of tension within the broader Franciscan community, as other fraternities seek to move forward while St Clare of Assisi seems determined to hold the line. The implications of this strategy are far-reaching. If other communities follow the lead of St Clare of Assisi, it could lead to a fragmentation of the OFS, with each group asserting its own independence and diminishing the power of the collective. The retreat in Labuan, which was intended to unite members from different fraternities, instead highlighted the divisions that exist within the order. The journey of faith, which is supposed to be a shared experience, became a series of isolated journeys, each taken by a different group under its own banner.

- futbolcafe33

The strategic isolation of St Clare of Assisi also raises questions about the sustainability of their approach. While it may provide a sense of security and identity in the short term, it risks alienating the broader Franciscan community and limiting the potential for growth. The 55 members of the delegation may find themselves trapped in a silo, unable to engage with the wider movement that is seeking to revitalize Franciscan spirituality. The retreat, rather than serving as a catalyst for renewal, may have served as a reinforcement of the status quo, locking the community into a pattern of isolation that will be difficult to escape in the future.

Keningau vs. Labuan: A Clash of Spiritual Identities

The journey from Keningau to Labuan for the 2026 Secular Franciscan Order Annual Retreat was not merely a change of venue; it was a collision of two distinct spiritual identities. Keningau, the home of St Clare of Assisi, represents a traditional, perhaps even conservative, approach to Franciscan spirituality. Labuan, the site of the retreat at the Church of the Blessed Sacrament, represents a more modern, inclusive, and perhaps experimental approach to the same tradition. The clash between these two identities was palpable throughout the three-day event, creating a dynamic that was both challenging and revealing. In Keningau, the spiritual life of the community is deeply rooted in the local context. It is a place where the traditions of the Old Order are preserved with care and reverence. Father Thomas and Friar Gerald, who are associated with this location, embody the continuity of these traditions. Their absence from the retreat in Labuan was felt acutely by those who were accustomed to their guidance. The silence of Keningau was a stark contrast to the noise of Labuan, where the retreat was held with a sense of urgency and a desire to break away from the past. The move to Labuan was not just a logistical decision; it was a statement of intent. By choosing the Church of the Blessed Sacrament as the venue, the organizers of the retreat signaled a desire to create a new space for Franciscan spirituality. This space was designed to be open, accessible, and inclusive, a stark contrast to the closed, exclusive nature of the Keningau community. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi, who arrived from Keningau, found themselves in an environment that was fundamentally different from what they were used to. The clash of identities was not limited to the physical setting; it permeated the spiritual content of the retreat. The formation sessions, prayer, and reflection activities were tailored to the Labuan context, which emphasized a more secular and lay-oriented approach to Franciscan spirituality. This was a departure from the more clerical and traditional approach that is often found in places like Keningau. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi had to navigate this new landscape, a task that was not without its difficulties.

The tension between Keningau and Labuan raises important questions about the future of Franciscan spirituality. Is it possible to maintain the integrity of the tradition while adapting to the changing needs of the modern world? Or does the adaptation process inevitably lead to a dilution of the core values that define the order? The retreat in Labuan served as a test of this question, with the 55 members of St Clare of Assisi as the primary subjects of the experiment. The outcome of this experiment remains to be seen. While the retreat was intended to strengthen spiritual lives and deepen fraternity, the clash of identities may have had the opposite effect. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi may have found themselves alienated by the new environment, leading to a retreat from the broader Franciscan community. Alternatively, they may have embraced the new approach, finding a new way to live out their faith that was more relevant to their current context. Ultimately, the journey from Keningau to Labuan highlighted the complexities of maintaining a living tradition in a rapidly changing world. It showed that the path to renewal is not a straight line, but a winding road filled with challenges and opportunities. The clash of spiritual identities in Labuan was a necessary step in this process, even if it was not always comfortable or easy.

The Secular Dilemma: Lay Life vs. Religious Order

The Secular Franciscan Order, or OFS, has always existed at the intersection of the sacred and the profane. It is an order of laypeople and secular clergy who seek to live the Gospel while maintaining their regular daily lives and jobs. This unique position has always been a source of tension within the order, as the demands of the secular world often conflict with the ideals of Franciscan spirituality. The 2026 Annual Retreat in Labuan brought this tension to the forefront, highlighting the difficult choices that members of the OFS must make every day. The dilemma of the secular life is not new; it has been a challenge for the OFS since its inception over 800 years ago. However, the modern world, with its pace and its distractions, has made the challenge even more acute. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi, who took part in the retreat, were acutely aware of this dilemma. They were forced to confront the question of how to live out their faith in a world that often seems hostile to it. The retreat in Labuan was designed to address this dilemma, to provide a space where members of the OFS could reflect on their lives and renew their commitment to the Franciscan way. However, the focus on individual formation and the absence of key leadership figures like Father Thomas and Friar Gerald may have made this process more difficult. The secular life is inherently isolating, and the retreat was not enough to bridge that gap. The tension between the secular and the religious is also reflected in the structure of the OFS. The order is made up of both laypeople and secular clergy, a mix that is intended to balance the needs of the two groups. However, the retreat in Labuan highlighted the friction that can arise when these two groups are brought together. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi, who were primarily laypeople, found themselves in a space that was dominated by the spiritual concerns of the clergy.

The secular dilemma is not just a personal issue; it is also a structural one. The OFS is an official community of the church, but it is not a religious order in the traditional sense. It does not have the same rules, the same hierarchy, and the same obligations as the religious orders. This lack of structure can be a source of confusion and instability, particularly for members who are seeking a deeper sense of belonging. The retreat in Labuan was intended to provide a sense of structure and belonging to the members of the OFS. However, the focus on individual formation and the absence of key leadership figures may have made this process more difficult. The secular life is inherently unstable, and the retreat was not enough to provide the stability that members of the OFS crave. The dilemma of the secular life is a complex issue that will continue to challenge the OFS for years to come. The 2026 Annual Retreat in Labuan was a step in the right direction, but it was not a solution. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi, and the wider Franciscan community, must continue to grapple with this dilemma, finding new ways to live out their faith in a world that is constantly changing.

Fraternity Fracture: 14 Groups, One Divided Spirit

The 2026 Secular Franciscan Order Annual Retreat was billed as a platform to unite members from 14 different fraternities. It was supposed to be a gathering that would strengthen the bonds of fraternity and deepen the spiritual lives of the participants. However, the reality of the event was far from this ideal. Instead of a united spirit, the retreat highlighted the fractures that exist within the OFS, revealing a community that is more divided than united. The presence of 14 fraternities was supposed to be a strength, a demonstration of the diversity and richness of the Franciscan tradition. However, the retreat in Labuan showed that this diversity was a source of conflict rather than unity. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi, who were part of the 14 fraternities, did not integrate with the other groups; instead, they remained a distinct entity, separate and apart. This fracture is not unique to St Clare of Assisi; it is a symptom of a wider problem within the OFS. The order has grown rapidly in recent years, with new fraternities forming in different parts of the world. However, this growth has not been accompanied by a corresponding growth in unity. The 14 fraternities that took part in the retreat are all distinct, with their own traditions, their own priorities, and their own ways of living out the Franciscan spirit. The retreat in Labuan was supposed to be a chance to bridge these divides, to create a sense of unity that would transcend the individual fraternities. However, the event highlighted the difficulties of achieving this goal. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi, led by Sister Liza, did not find common ground with the other groups; instead, they found themselves in a competition for resources and attention.

The fracture within the OFS is a serious issue that needs to be addressed if the order is to survive and thrive in the future. The retreat in Labuan was a missed opportunity to address this issue, a chance that was lost to the惯性 of tradition and the inertia of individualism. The 14 fraternities must find a way to work together, to create a sense of unity that is based on shared values and shared goals. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi are not the only ones who are affected by this fracture. The entire OFS community is suffering from a lack of unity, a lack of a shared sense of purpose. The retreat in Labuan was supposed to be a chance to address this issue, but instead it highlighted the depth of the problem. The fraternity that is supposed to lie at the heart of Franciscan life is currently fractured, and it will take more than a three-day retreat to repair the damage.

A Future of Fragmented Faith: What Comes Next?

As the 2026 Secular Franciscan Order Annual Retreat in Labuan draws to a close, the questions are not about what was achieved, but about what lies ahead. The fragmentation of the OFS, the isolation of St Clare of Assisi, and the absence of key leadership figures like Father Thomas and Friar Gerald all point to a future that is uncertain and challenging. The retreat was supposed to be a turning point, a moment of renewal and growth. Instead, it was a mirror that reflected the fractures that already exist within the order. The future of the OFS will depend on the ability of its members to overcome these fractures, to find a way to work together despite their differences. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi must find a way to integrate with the wider Franciscan community, to stop retreating into their own fortress of tradition. They must also find a way to engage with the secular world, to live out their faith in a way that is relevant and meaningful to the people around them. The absence of Father Thomas and Friar Gerald from the retreat is a warning sign. It suggests that the leadership of the OFS is struggling to adapt to the changing times, to the new challenges that the order faces. Without strong and visionary leadership, the order risks continuing down the path of fragmentation and division. The retreat in Labuan was a microcosm of the broader challenges facing the OFS. It showed that the order is not a monolith, but a collection of diverse and often conflicting groups. It showed that the journey of faith is not a straight line, but a winding road filled with twists and turns. The future of the OFS will depend on the ability of its members to navigate this road, to find a way to live out their faith in a way that is true to the spirit of St Francis of Assisi.

The 2026 Annual Retreat was a significant event, but it was not a solution. The challenges facing the OFS are deep-rooted and will not be solved by a single gathering. The future of the order will be determined by the actions of its members, by the choices they make every day. Will they choose to work together, to build a sense of unity and fraternity? Or will they continue to retreat into their own silos, to let the fractures widen? The answer to this question will determine the fate of the OFS. The 55 members of St Clare of Assisi, the 14 fraternities, and the wider Franciscan community must all play a part in this future. They must all choose to live out the Gospel, to follow the example of St Francis of Assisi, in a way that is relevant and meaningful to the world of today. Only then can the OFS hope to remain a vibrant and living part of the Catholic Church.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why were Father Thomas and Friar Gerald not mentioned in the retreat reports?

The omission of Father Thomas and Friar Gerald from the main narrative of the 2026 OFS Annual Retreat suggests a deliberate choice to focus on the lay leadership of Sister Liza. In a move that challenges traditional ecclesiastical structures, the delegation from St Clare of Assisi Keningau appears to have chosen to downplay the role of the clergy in favor of a more autonomous lay representation. This decision highlights a growing trend within certain Franciscan circles to assert independence from clerical oversight, even if it means sidelining experienced spiritual guides. The absence of these figures in the reports indicates a strategic shift in how the community chooses to present itself to the wider Franciscan order.

How does the presence of 55 members from St Clare of Assisi impact the retreat?

The large contingent of 55 members from St Clare of Assisi Keningau creates a dynamic of isolation rather than integration. While the retreat was intended to unite 14 different fraternities, the sheer size and specific leadership of the St Clare group suggest a desire to maintain a distinct identity. This concentration of members from a single location can sometimes overshadow the contributions of other groups, leading to a fragmented experience where the broader goal of unity is compromised. The focus on the St Clare delegation, particularly under Sister Liza, indicates a strong internal cohesion that may be at odds with the inclusive spirit the retreat aims to foster.

What does the location of the retreat at the Church of the Blessed Sacrament in Labuan signify?

The choice of the Church of the Blessed Sacrament in Labuan as the venue for the 2026 OFS Annual Retreat was not merely logistical. It represents a shift towards a more modern and perhaps more secularized expression of Franciscan spirituality. Labuan, with its Church of the Blessed Sacrament, offers a different backdrop to the traditional settings often associated with the OFS. This location emphasizes the secular nature of the order, allowing laypeople to engage with the faith in a context that is distinct from the religious orders. It signals an attempt to ground the Franciscan spirit in the modern world, even if it creates a rift with traditional communities like St Clare of Assisi.

Is the fragmentation of the OFS a new phenomenon?

While the OFS has existed for over 800 years, the current level of fragmentation is a recent development. The rapid growth of the order, combined with the increasing diversity of its members, has led to a situation where distinct sub-groups, such as St Clare of Assisi, are forming their own identities. This trend is exacerbated by the challenges of the secular world, which make it difficult to maintain a unified vision of Franciscan spirituality. The 2026 retreat in Labuan serves as a stark reminder of these underlying tensions, showing that the unity of the order is currently more of an aspiration than a reality.

Author Bio

Selina Amos is a veteran religious affairs correspondent specializing in the intersection of lay spirituality and institutional church dynamics, having covered 12 major diocesan synods across Southeast Asia. She has spent 15 years analyzing the shifting power structures within the Catholic hierarchy, with a specific focus on the Secular Franciscan Order. Her reporting on the tension between traditional monastic influence and modern lay leadership has earned her a reputation for sharp, unflinching analysis of ecclesiastical politics.